Should Queenstown tax empty homes? The case for and against

Regular Blogs
Should Queenstown tax empty homes? The case for and against

More than a quarter of the homes in Queenstown Lakes District were unoccupied on census night in 2023. Stats NZ counted 6,882 unoccupied private dwellings out of 25,101, or 27.4%, against 10.8% nationally.

Queenstown Lakes District Council councillors discussed short-term visitor accommodation at a workshop on 10 November, The Press reported, where staff recommended focusing on affordable housing rather than further restrictions on short-term rentals. An empty home tax isn’t a council proposal. The idea comes from Julie Scott, chief executive of the Queenstown Lakes Community Housing Trust, and it has councillors on both sides.

The case for

A council report to its Smart Growth committee in July put the median mortgage payment at 77.5% of median income, against 39.9% nationally, using Infometrics figures, and showed the housing trust’s waiting list growing from 980 households in June 2023 to 1,592 in June 2026. MBIE bond data puts the district’s median weekly rent at $780 in September, up from $750 a year earlier and well above the national $599.

The same report showed Queenstown Lakes consents 34 homes per 1,000 residents, against 7.3 nationally, and Scott told The Press the district doesn’t have a housing shortage in the traditional sense, but a shortage of homes available to locals on low to moderate incomes. Deputy Mayor Quentin Smith told the workshop, “Empty houses are one of the things that rip the guts out of local communities.” Cr Niki Gladding said she didn’t support giving up on the issue in favour of inclusionary zoning.

The case against

Mayor John Glover has said holiday homes are a normal part of tourism towns around the world and that the district operates in a free market, RNZ reported in January. He would rather the council captured some of the value created when land is rezoned for more housing. In the same report, former World Bank senior economist Ralph Hanan said it was a long shot to expect holiday-home owners to open their houses to tenants for nine or 10 months a year.

The 2018 Tax Working Group’s paper on taxing vacant property, prepared by Inland Revenue and Treasury, found very little evidence that such taxes increase housing supply and recommended no further work on one. Cr Melissa White raised the practical problem at the workshop, saying the threshold for penalising anyone is high and the council would carry the cost of proving it.

Opes Partners managing partner Andrew Nicol, in the same RNZ report, said he’d seen rental yields as low as 3% in the district, and linked tenancy rules to owners choosing to leave homes empty or limit lettings to 90 days.

What it would take

Under the Local Government (Rating) Act 2002, councils can set different general rates only by the matters listed in the Act, such as how land is used, its zoning, location or value, and occupancy isn’t one of them. The Department of Internal Affairs advised the Tax Working Group in 2018 that it was doubtful a council could set a differential rate for vacant housing under the law as it stood, and that councils had no ready way of knowing whether a property was empty.

The council said in an Official Information Act reply in May that it doesn’t classify rating units as holiday homes or non-primary residences. It does track short-term rentals, with 5,356 properties registered for short-term visitor accommodation as at 1 July 2025, and owners need a resource consent to let a home for more than 90 nights a year.

On that 2018 advice, an empty home rate would most likely need a change to the rating law first. Scott has called for legislation that would let councils use appropriate tools, while the Government’s Local Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill, which passed its first reading in September, would set a target range for rates increases of 2% to 4%. Neither is likely to move until a government forms after the official election results on 27 November.

Date: November 19, 2026